Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Coverage of Rick Perry's vaccine misadventure misses the point

Recent media coverage of the heated debate over Texas Governor Rick Perry's endorsement of mandatory HPV vaccinations for school-age girls in his state seems to be missing a few crucial points. First, many of the medical groups who strongly endorsed the vaccine to prevent cervical cancer received funding from Merck, the maker of the vaccine in question, Gardasil. And two, Merck's aggressive marketing campaign to sell the vaccine as a preventative measure against a relatively rare type of cancer (cervical cancer) in middle-class teenage girls completely ignored poorer populations that are at much higher risk of developing this cancer.

Such concerns were amplified in a thoughtful 2009 paper in the Journal of the American Medical Association(JAMA), and reported by Gary Schwitzer's Healthnews blog and Gooznews.

As the JAMA researchers noted:
As marketing of this HPV (short for human papilloma virus) vaccine demonstrates, pharmaceutical company campaigns can undercut the most cost-effective and appropriate use of new agents to the detriment of adolescent health. By making this vaccine's target disease cervical cancer, the sexual transmission of HPV was minimized, the threat of cervical cancer to all adolescents maximized, and the subpopulations most at risk practically ignored.

Recent news reports do mention that Perry himself had substantial conflicts of interest when he signed an executive order mandating HPV vaccines for school-age girls, making him the only governor in the union to do so. As the San Francisco Chronicle notes, Perry has received at least $23,500 in campaign contributions from Merck, including $5,000 in 2006, the year before he ordered girls throughout the state to take the HPV vaccine. Merck also has donated about $500,000 to the Republican Governors Association, a group which Perry headed twice and has been among his most generous campaign donors. As the Chronicle and the New York Times also point out, Perry issued the executive order at a time when his former chief of staff was a lobbyist for Merck.

But the Times article fails to note the egregious conflicts of interest among key physician groups that strongly endorsed the vaccine for school-age girls. As the 2009 JAMA article pointed out, Merck provided educational grants to groups like the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, the American Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology (ASCCP), the Society of Gynecologic Oncologists (SGO), and the American College Health Association (ACHA), all of whom strongly recommended the vaccine in school-age girls.

The recent coverage also doesn't explore the public health costs and benefits of mandating vaccines for affluent school-age girls, which, as Gooznews notes, doesn't make a lot of financial sense. About 3,600 women die from cervical cancer every year -- compared to approximately 40,000 who die from breast cancer annually. Yet Merck itself estimated it would cost $1.4 to $1.6 billion to immunize young girls from the disease, which can be picked up fairly easily (and much more cheaply) with regular pap smears.

As the JAMA researchers were the first to note, it would make far more sense to spend the money paying for pap smears for poorer women who have multiple partners but no health insurance.

I have to say I find it ironic that Perry is being lambasted by his Republican rivals for mandating something they say should have been left up to families to decide, which is the primary focus of today's Times piece. But I wish the media would use this opportunity to explore the public health ramifications of allowing a drug manufacturer to aggressively target the wrong population for an expensive and possibly unnecessary vaccine.

9 comments:

nhokkanen said...

As the mother of a son who sadly, paradoxically, suffered adverse reactions to vaccines:
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.

preeti said...

Strong steps should be taken for cervical cancer cure or avoid this big health problem. Many health problems could be cured easily if they could be diagnose earlier as early treatment of meniscus tear by menisectomy
.

Ronald Vaughn said...

Many thnx for that posting, i discovered quite distinct angle at Levitra
Charlot

Darren said...

Yet Merck itself estimated it would cost $1.4 to $1.6 billion to immunize young buy vardenafil girls from the disease, which can be picked up fairly easily (and much more cheaply) with regular pap smears.

Hubert Haley said...

One of the more vocal among them is blogger and UW Law School professor Ann Althouse, who has Phentermine 37.5 gone to great and terrible lengths to excuse the alleged behavior, attack the credibility of only kamagra uk the anonymous sources with whom she disagrees, suggest that no arrests (yet) mean no wrongdoing, impugn Levitra Online the honor of Justice Bradley, and cast doubt on the very justice system of this state.

John said...

Thanks for the post. It can be really hard putting your life together. I know that drug addiction intervention can make a big difference but, can be difficult to do on your own. Get help today.

Pearly Craig said...

I don't get it why FDA approve such drugs if the are not yet perfected and in the end just cause misery to the patients.
child psychologist Denver

Robert Gomez said...

Thank you for sharing your unique perspective and message of hope. It is very good to be reminded that language and "knowledge" can dissociate us not only from others but from ourselves. vasectomy NC

poul smith said...

I wanted to say Thank You for providing this information, youre doing a great job with the site if you get a chance would you help me make some changes to
http://tryvitalcleansecomplete.com/